Comparison
Both pick a random comment as a giveaway winner. Comment Picker covers many social networks; Hadzy is YouTube-only, and searches the whole comment section it draws from.
Plenty of creators end up using both: Comment Picker for their Instagram draws, Hadzy for the YouTube ones.
Proof page
Hadzy draws from every comment on the video, then puts the winner on a public page: the winning comment, the size of the pool and the time of the draw.
| Feature | Hadzy | Comment Picker |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | HadzyYouTube only | Comment PickerYouTube, Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, X |
| What it is | HadzyComment search engine with a giveaway picker built in | Comment PickerGiveaway picker inside a large suite of generic tools (list randomizer, coin flip, wheel of names, thumbnail downloader) |
| Free-tier comment depth | HadzyThe draw covers every comment on the video. Reading them is what the free tier meters: 250 results per search, 250 rows per export | Comment PickerAround 100 comments per YouTube draw |
| Ads and affiliate links | HadzyNone, on any tier | Comment PickerShown on the free tier; removed on Premium |
| Full-text comment search | HadzyYes - keyword and author search across the whole comment section | Comment PickerNo - it is a picker, not a search tool |
| Statistics | HadzyWord cloud, top commenters, timeline stats | Comment PickerNot offered |
| Multi-video draws | HadzyNo - one video per draw | Comment PickerPremium: draw across up to 5 videos |
| Winners per draw | Hadzy1 free; up to 10 in a batch draw for supporters | Comment PickerUp to 10 on Premium |
| Entry filters | HadzySupporters: keyword, minimum word count, one entry per person | Comment PickerPremium: entry forms |
| Shareable result | HadzyFree public proof page at hadzy.com/g/{proofId} that anyone can open | Comment PickerPremium: saved results and a white-label results page (your logo, title, colour) |
| Signup | HadzyNone needed; supporter features unlock through Patreon | Comment PickerFree tier usable in-browser; Premium is an account |
| Price | HadzyFree; optional supporter tier $5/month via Patreon | Comment PickerFree with ads; Premium $9.99/month or $95.91/year |
Yes, there is a free tier. On YouTube it draws from roughly the first 100 comments and the free pages carry ads and affiliate links. Premium costs $9.99 per month or $95.91 per year and adds draws across up to 5 videos, up to 10 winners, saved results, entry forms, a white-label results page, and removes the ads. Hadzy has no ads or affiliate links on any tier, and its optional supporter plans start at $5 per month through Patreon.
No. Hadzy is YouTube-only. If your giveaway runs on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, or X, Comment Picker is the right tool - it covers all of those, and Hadzy has no plans that change that.
Hadzy. It loads the video’s full comment thread through the official YouTube Data API, so a draw on a video with tens of thousands of comments considers all of them. Comment Picker’s free YouTube draw works from about the first 100 comments. Hadzy’s free tier has its own limits - 250 results per search and 250 rows per CSV export - but those cap what you can read and download, not what the draw considers.
Hadzy puts the winner of a draw on a public proof page at hadzy.com/g/{proofId}, with the size of the pool and the time of the draw. It is free, including for a single winner, and needs no login. You paste that link in your announcement and entrants open it themselves - no screenshot to trust. Comment Picker offers saved results and a white-label results page on its Premium tier.
Comment Picker. It has been running since 2015 and has a much longer public track record, along with a broad suite of general-purpose tools beyond giveaways. Hadzy is a newer, narrower tool focused on YouTube comment search and analysis.
Paste the video link - the draw and its proof page are free and need no account.